Campaign performance: simple playbook

Compare each campaign’s share of spend with its share of sales. Use the efficiency index and the four quadrants to decide which campaigns to scale, trim or pause.

Where does this campaign sit?
Low spendHigh spend
High sales Q2 · Hidden gemsScale Q1 · WhalesProtect
Low sales Q4 · NoiseMonitor Q3 · Money pitsCut waste

The two basic shares (the starting point)

Spend %

What it is: How much of the total ad money this one campaign is eating.

Why you care: If a campaign takes a big slice of money but doesn’t bring matching sales, it’s quietly draining you.

Why it goes wrong:

  • Over-broad targeting
  • Aggressive “top of search” boosts
  • Missing negative keywords
  • Pricey categories
  • Your own brand terms eating budget you don’t need to spend

Fast fixes:

  • Lower daily budget
  • Reduce top-of-search boost
  • Cut bids 10–30% in steps
  • Add negatives from the last 30–60 days
  • Split exact match from “explore” targets so you can control each cleanly

Sales %

What it is: How much of total revenue this campaign actually brings in.

Why you care: This is the point of running ads.

Why it goes wrong:

  • Not enough traffic
  • Weak click-through or conversion
  • Out of stock
  • Weak product page
  • Bad price
  • Wrong match types
  • Spending on search terms that don’t buy

Fast fixes:

  • Improve product page (price, images, reviews)
  • Mine the search term report; add converting terms as exact
  • Move budget to proven themes
  • Tighten match types
  • Test better creatives
  • Make sure you hold the Buy Box and have stock

Push or pull: the signals that tell you what to do

Efficiency Index (EI)

Formula: EI = Sales% ÷ Spend%

How to read it:

  • EI > 1 → This campaign beats your account average.
  • EI < 1 → It underperforms.

Why it goes wrong (low EI):

  • Bids too high; over-boosted placements
  • Junk search terms; weak-intent category targets
  • Product page problems

Fast fixes for low EI:

  • Cut bids and boosts
  • Pause or negate waste terms
  • Move “prospecting” into its own small budget
  • Retest placements

Fast scale for high EI:

  • Raise budget caps; nudge bids on exact winners
  • Copy winners into Sponsored Brands/Video
  • Try a small top-of-search boost (+10–20%)
  • Watch ACOS

Gap (Sales vs Spend)

Formula: Gap = Sales% − Spend%

How to read it:

  • Positive number → More sales than the money it takes (good).
  • Negative number → Takes more money than sales it returns (bad).

Why it goes wrong (big negative):

  • Exploration mixed with core
  • Broad match hoovering random traffic
  • Old keywords past their peak; seasonal drop
  • Competitors cut prices

Fast fixes:

  • Lower budget; split tests into a separate campaign
  • Add strong negatives; reset placement boosts
  • Re-bid using click and conversion data (don’t feed dead targets)

Relative ACOS

Formula: Relative ACOS = (Spend% ÷ Sales%) × Account ACOS

What it is: The campaign’s ACOS, expressed in the same “units” as your account target to rank easily.

When it’s high: Same causes as low EI plus price/page issues.

Fast fixes: Cut bids, trim boosts, remove weak targets, or fix the product page/price. Ads can’t rescue a bad offer.

Weighted ACOS Impact

Formula: Weighted Impact = Spend% × (Relative ACOS − Account ACOS)

What it tells you: How much this campaign pushes your whole account ACOS up or down; a “drag meter.”

  • High & positive (bad): Freeze budget, slash boosts, keep only exact winners, move experiments elsewhere.
  • Strongly negative (good): Feed budget, expand to SB/SBV, protect winners with exact match, defend against rising CPCs.

Opportunity Score

Formula: Opportunity = max(0, (Sales% − Spend%) ÷ Sales%)

What it tells you: 0–1 “headroom” score. Higher = you’re under-funding a winner.

Why it’s high:

  • Bids too conservative; no top-of-search boost
  • Winner buried in a mixed ad group
  • Daily budget is capping

Fast scale:

  • Add 15–30% budget; add 5–15% bids on proven exacts
  • Small top-of-search boost
  • Clone to new match types or similar intents
  • Extend ad hours

Quadrants: your one-look map

Q1 · Whales (High Spend and High Sales)

Role: Core revenue engines.

Why they win: Strong brand terms, proven exacts, good pages, stable rank.

Fast actions: Protect and scale. Raise budgets, test small top-of-search boosts, copy winners to Sponsored Brands/Video, watch stock and TACoS.

Q2 · Hidden Gems (Low Spend, High Sales)

Role: Under-fed winners.

Why they’re hidden: Bids too low, no boost, mixed with other stuff, budget caps.

Fast actions: Raise budget, nudge bids on exact winners, isolate into their own campaigns, add look-alike targets, expand to new regions/placements.

Q3 · Money Pits (High Spend, Low Sales)

Role: The drain.

Why they sink: Broad match waste, weak-intent categories, bad price/page, competitor squeeze, off-season.

Fast actions: Cut bids 20–40%, cap budgets, remove or negate bad targets, trim boosts, move tests out, keep only items that re-prove themselves.

Q4 · Noise (Low Spend, Low Sales)

Role: Long tail and experiments.

Why they exist: New or niche ideas, low volume.

Fast actions: Keep them cheap if clicks are cheap and EI ≥ 1; otherwise pause. Promote anything that starts to work into Q2 or Q1 structures.

How to run this day to day

Campaign performance report in AiHello

1) Triage order

  • Sort by Weighted ACOS Impact; fix the worst harm first.
  • Sort by Opportunity Score; feed the most starved winners.
  • Check EI trends for the last 7, 14, and 30 days.

2) Guardrails

  • Don’t judge new stuff too fast. Give it at least 20–40 clicks and 2–3 conversions.
  • Split Brand vs Non-Brand, and Exact vs Broad/Auto. Mixed signals make dumb decisions.
  • If inventory covers < 14 days or you’re losing the Buy Box, pause the scaling.

3) If the ads look “off,” check the product

  • Price changes, coupons ending, page edits, stockouts, review swings, competitor sales will swing EI/ACOS fast.

4) Time windows

  • Use the last 30–35 days for stable decisions.
  • Peek at the last 7 days for momentum.
  • Treat big sale weeks (Prime, Black Friday) separately.

TL;DR (the quick moves)

  • Scale it: EI > 1, Gap (Sales% − Spend%) > 0, and high Opportunity Score → add budget, nudge bids, small top-of-search boost, copy to SB/SBV.
  • Fix it: EI < 1 or negative Gap with big Weighted Impact → cut bids/boosts, cap budget, prune targets, add negatives, move tests out.
  • Park it: Q4 can idle if clicks are cheap and EI holds; otherwise pause.
  • Protect it: Q1 “whales” get inventory checks, exact-match protection, and careful boosts don’t starve winners.

That’s it. Feed winners, stop the leaks, and keep the math simple and honest.